I’ve travelled to more than 50 cities in 30 countries over the past 8 years conducting employer branding events and delivering training to thousands of leaders across all industry sectors and company sizes - It’s been an amazing journey. Around half of the events have been in emerging markets, a categorisations of companies used to describe a country that has some characteristics of a developed market, but does not meet standards to be a developed market. Examples include the traditional BRIC countries, Brazil, Russia, India and China. BRIC is acronym coined in 2001 by Jim O'Neill from Goldman Sachs in a paper entitled "Building Better Global Economic BRICs. Other examples include Turkey, Chile, Latvia and Uzbekistan, a country I am travelling to this week to train senior leaders in employer brand strategy and leadership.
It is my second visit to Tashkent after my initial visit in 2013 to present at a conference and University Forum on recruiting young talent. It is also the country I experienced my first earthquake (the locals called it nothing unusual!) but that is a whole other story!
In 2011 my company, Employer Brand International entered a joint venture in Russia with the country’s largest online job board and over the next two years we built an employer branding consulting business and launched the country’s largest Employer Branding Summit. We also welcomed Russia and Ukraine to our global survey platform to conduct research into what was driving talent attraction, engagement and retention in these markets. My second book, ‘Employer Brand Leadership-A Global Perspective’ was also translated into Russian and published in 2011.
I have been exposed to a lot during my travels in Russia and other emerging markets and it is these experiences which have changed my perceptions about these countries which had been shaped growing up under the influence of messages portrayed by Australian and International media.
My travels and collaborations with leaders in emerging markets has also enlightened me to what is possible if companies in these markets were to adopt the employer brand concept as a way of acquiring and managing talent to grow their companies (and economies). The starting point should be to look holistically at the employee experience from pre-hire to retire and how this impacts on the customer experience and profitability.
The key to success in emerging markets will require a change in mindset amongst leaders who traditionally see human resources (the traditional custodians of the employer brand) as an operational function. It doesn’t matter whether the employer brand strategy is driven by the HR department or the marketing department, what matters is the company adopting a strategic approach to employer branding that is aligned with organisational objectives. Without the right people companies failure to grow! The same challenges exist in develop markets and companies need to upskill leaders on employer branding knowledge, competency and practice. The resources to support a formal or informal approach towards this development are now more accessible in emerging markets than they have been in the past 10 years due to accessibility through the internet.
We have also found from our research and consulting in emerging markets that investment in employer branding has predominantly been focused on recruitment strategies over the past five years. This is only part of the solution! The world’s leading employer brands such as Google, IKEA, Air New Zealand and P&G have invested in appointing dedicated employer branding personnel, something I am yet to see in emerging markets. Companies in developed world countries such as USA, United Kingdom and Australia companies have increased investment in employer branding following the 2009 global financial crisis. However this is a key area where companies in emerging markets are lagging.
The advantages for leaders in emerging markets include:
An opportunity to build leader engagement in employer brand strategy as it is a new topic and companies do not have the history of failed campaigns that limited employer brand strategy to a recruitment function and/or standalone EVP project.
The cost of conducting employer branding projects are less in emerging markets as the cost of labour is cheaper. This does not have to come at the expense of quality as there is now more access to best practice through books, videos and other resources at the touch of a mouse click.
Launching employer brand surveys to develop own benchmarks to track over time. There is a decreasing appetite for the expensive annual employee engagement and/or culture survey conducted by external vendors. Companies are seeking real time feedback on the mood or sentiment of employees so they can make changes in real time and keep employees focused on achieving organisational objectives.
Access to best practice methodology and case studies of successful employer brand management which didn’t exist 10 years ago when companies in developed markets began increasing their investments in employer branding. Resources are usually leaner in emerging markets so leaders have less to spend on employer branding initiatives so they will try and make every dollar count compared to the wastage that occurs in developed markets from ad hoc strategies.
Technology and growth of social sites such as LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook into emerging markets has also provide exceptional opportunities for leaders in emerging markets to gain accessibility to best practice, knowledge and key influencers in employer branding.
One area I have found consistent in employees across the world is what they are seeking from an employment experience. This usually falls in the following five areas (albeit in different priority):
Fair pay for fair work
Treated with respect
Meaningful work – feeling like I am making a positive contribution
Enjoy working with the people around me
Personal and career development
So how can leaders in emerging markets ensure their companies can be early adopters of the employer brand concept and develop strategy which will positon their company as a place people want to join and contribute to their success?
Conduct an internal audit of your employer brand including an employee experience survey to understand how employees perceive the employment experience and the key areas in the employment lifecycle which have the highest emotional impact between employee and employer.
Follow twitter hashtags such as, #employerbranding, #employerbrand, etc, employer branding best practice companies and key industry influencers on LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter to stay on top of latest developments in employer branding
Connect and engage with 50 other employer branding leaders around the world on LinkedIn to learn from them
All of the above initiatives can be undertaken at a minimal cost to what companies in developed markets have had to invest in the past ten years to achieve a similar outcome. A big opportunity awaits for leaders in emerging markets!
We are continuously exposed to brand experiences throughout our day either as a consumer, employee or candidate. The reality is these experiences are rarely distinctive, consistent or deliver what is expected based on the perception people have about the brand. An opportunity missed!
As a key differentiator for brand experience success, organizations have traditionally focused on the customer experience . However, what’s been missing has been an understanding of the role of the employee in the relationship between organizations, customers and profitability!
Employees are central to the customer experience and organizations must adopt an integrated approach towards brand experience if they are to remain relevant to the needs of customers and the talent that drive these experiences.
In this whitepaper Minchington and Morris focus on the importance of the employee experience, its impact on the customer experience and present a model for creating and sustaining a distinctive, integrated brand experience. The authors also provide detailed insights into how to develop a strategy to optimize employee experience, customer loyalty and profitability.
For a limited time you can download a free copy of the whitepaper by clicking on the button below.
15 Employer branding best practices to focus on in 2015
I was fortunate to share many wonderful moments with friends and partners during my 2014 Employer Brand Global Tour which took me to London, New York, Milan, Vilnius, Toronto, Sydney, Perth, Cluj, Bucharest, Vienna, Stockholm and Singapore! On the way home (24hrs of flying) I reflected as I always do at this time of the year to think about the year ahead.
I’ve now travelled to more than 50 cities in 30 countries on my employer branding global tours since 2007 and each city I visit provides new insights into the challenges and successes companies are experiencing in developing, implementing and managing their employer brand strategy.
2015 will be a break out year for the employer branding industry if the trend of companies hiring dedicated employer brand leaders continues as it has over the past few years. We will see a tipping point in employer branding in 2015 which will be led by the USA where the economic growth forecast suggests companies will begin hiring again. However even in a growth market talent is getting harder to find. Getting your employer brand strategy right will require a dedicated and disciplined approach by the leader driving the strategy with strong support from leaders across all lines of business.
It's been great to observe in 2014 the trend of companies such as Google, Facebook, 3M, UnitedHealth Group, IBM, EY, Repsol and Amtrak engage employer branding talent to manage their strategy and shift their focus of employer branding from an add on function in an already over worked HR department to a strategic one.
Our 2014 Employer Branding Global Research Study report also provided insights into how employer branding has evolved in 18 key regions around the world over the past 5 years. For a complimentary copy of the report please download at the end of this paper.
Below is a list of 15 key focus areas which will assist you in your journey throughout 2015 and whilst not all may be achieved in 2015, having an understanding of these trending areas for employer branding will keep you focus in the right direction in a management field which is growing in importance in companies all over the world and one which will continue to challenge the value of traditional functional departments such as HR, marketing and communications over the next 5 years. Success in business can no longer rely on out of date organisational structure and siloed functional departments. Today's pace of change requires organisations to adapt their business model to one that is agile and reactive to continuous market changes.
1.5 questions you must know the answer to:
These are five questions all leaders need to know the answer to!
They are also some great questions for candidates to ask at interview to assess how evolved the company is in their approach to employer branding.
Why would someone want to work for you?
What percentage of your managers have received training in how to deliver the brand experience? (Employer Brand International research found only 46% have!)
What is the perception employees and candidates have about your employer brand?
What level of visibility do you have of your employees/talent pool?
What percentage of your employees would recommend your company as a great place to work?
2.Adopt a strategic approach to employer branding across the employment lifecycle
In 2005 when I was finalising my first book, ‘Your Employer Brand attract-engage-retain’, I wanted to consolidate my research from the previous three years and develop a strategic framework to assist leaders to develop and manage their employer brand strategy. The Employer Brand Excellence FrameworkTM can be used to guide your employer brand program across the employee lifecycle from pre-hire to retire (see figure 1).
Successful implementation of the framework will ensure the promise to customers that is articulated by the company’s corporate and consumer brand is matched by the promise delivered to employees by your employer brand. The framework is even more relevant in today’s environment which requires companies to apply a ‘systems thinking’ view to how the employer brand impacts on the organisation’s ability to attract, engage and retain talent and the linkage between employees, customers and profit.
Systems thinking is the process of understanding how things influence one another within a whole. In organisations, systems consist of people, structures, and processes that work together to make an organisation healthy or unhealthy.
Too many companies and vendors still promote employer branding as a talent acquisition and/or recruitment function. Companies adopt this perspective usually due to a lack of awareness of the benefits of employer branding whilst vendors usually take this approach to support the business development of their products.
Focusing employer branding on talent acquisition only usually results in an improved recruitment and onboarding process that has very little impact on culture and/or business performance due to lack of consistency in the employee experience as they evolve through their tenure. Siloed organisational structures also do little to promote a strategic approach to employer branding because the HR personnel don't get along with the marketing and/or communications personnel. Exacerbating the situation further is executives that have very little awareness of employer branding so it ends up as an operational project that lives in the HR department but has very little impact on business performance.
A strategic approach to employer branding requires a strategic perspective towards how your company attracts, engages and retains talent. Undertake an employer brand audit and/or employee experience mapping project and hopefully the results will inspire your leaders to change their perspective and thinking on employer brand strategy and management.
Figure 1: Employer Brand Excellence FrameworkTM
3.Be clear on what you stand for!
Your organisation's mission, vision and values should be clearly defined and this should flow through to your employer branding communications. Two of the standout companies in this area are Apple and Starbucks.
Starbucks are very clear on what they stand for and their social media and content strategy is aligned with their key strategic objectives (see figure 2). Starbucks don’t just sell coffee, their mission is to:
‘To inspire and nurture the human spirit – one person, one cup and one neighborhood at a time.
This is supported by their values:
With our partners, our coffee and our customers at our core, we live these values:
•Creating a culture of warmth and belonging, where everyone is welcome.
•Acting with courage, challenging the status quo and finding new ways to grow our company and each other.
•Being present, connecting with transparency, dignity and respect.
•Delivering our very best in all we do, holding ourselves accountable for results.
•We are performance driven, through the lens of humanity.
Figure 2: CSR at Starbucks
4.Adopt a community concept to your employer brand strategy
Many of the world’s top companies such as P&G, Mars, Chevron and Google are thinking ‘Community’ in their approach to employer branding (see figure 3). They adopt a strategic approach across the employment lifecycle and consider all internal and external stakeholders in developing their strategy through an integrated corporate, consumer and employer, one brand lens.
Their employer branding 3.0 approach is focused on sustainable business practices at a time where corporate sustainability is being challenge by an increased focus on ethical resource allocations across energy, water and human resources.
Figure 3: Evolution of branding to a community concept
5.Understand that the world has changed!
Advertising no longer has the impact it once did! We are now in the age of the customer which has placed more responsibility on organisations to clearly define the role of employees in delivering signature employee experiences (see figure 4). If my experience is anything to go by, those that have flown with Singapore Airlines or Emirates (see figure 5) would have experienced a seamless experience from the moment they decided which airline to fly to when they exited the airport at their destination. This doesn’t happen by chance. It is a result of aligning the employer brand strategy at an organisational level so that HR systems, policies and processes have an impact across all lines of the business and influence company culture focused on optimising the customer experience on every single flight.
Figure 4: The age of the customer
Figure 5: Align the customer and employee experience
6.Be aware of political risks
The risks of shifting manufacturing and/or production offshore and/or recruiting talent from outside local borders has to be weighed up against the risks of not doing so. Increasingly due to the threat of terrorism, quality concerns and corporate agility, companies are reconsidering their appetite for political risks especially in industries such as construction and oil and gas. Outside of the USA, Australia, New Zealand, the UK and the Nordics, research by Maplecroft show medium to extreme levels of political risk in most other countries (see figure 6). One way companies will react to this risk is by engaging talent from these regions on a project by project basis as they become visible through their participation on professional networks such as LinkedIn and Facebook or other popular local networks.
Figure 6: Political risk
7.Understand economic trends and country primed for growth
The global economic forecast for 2020 is not as bad as one might think.
Whilst a decline of 5% is predicated in emerging markets, growth of 3.5% is expected in Eastern Europe, 2.3% in Eurasia, 5.6% in Asean, 3% in Latin America and 4.2% in Middle East and North Africa (see figure 7). There will also be opportunities for growth for companies who are able to localise their employer brand strategy in their key growth markets (see figure 8).
Figure 7: Global economic growth to 2020
Figure 8: The growth markets 2010 to 2020
8.Resolve the employer brand strategy ownership debate
It’s time to resolve the ownership debate.
Research by Employer Brand International shows a shift in employer brand strategy ownership away from HR over the past 5 years (see figure 9).
Whether the personnel responsible for the employer brand strategy come from human resources, marketing, communications or other function is not the debate we should be having. The focus should be on how your company develops a competent team of professionals sourced from inside and outside the firm who can develop and execute an employer brand strategy that builds value.
The traditional siloed approach to managing the attraction, engagement and retention of talent is out of date and out of step with today’s candidate and employee needs. More needs to be done by organisations to facilitate cross functional leadership of the employer branding function to ensure a more cohesive approach. In more than one hundred events I have presented at I can only recall one finance director in the audience (from Nike!) – There is little wonder why one of the biggest challenges for employer branding leaders is to gain budget approval for their employer brand strategy.
Figure 9: The shift in employer brand strategy ownership away from HR
9.Focus your employer branding resources
The focus for the employer brand leader is on recruitment at companies such as Facebook, Amazon and KPMG. However companies such as LinkedIn, IKEA and Amtrak have adopted a holistic approach to employer branding across the total employment lifecycle (see figure 10).
History shows that companies transition towards a strategic approach to employer brand management after two to three years of adopting the concept. This is consistent with how employer branding evolves inside a company as expertise and experience builds across the leadership teams.
It is clear that with the increasing talent shortages around the world we will begin to see many more follow the lead of companies such as Google, IBM, Marriott, 3M and EY in recruiting leaders to leverage the value an employer brand strategy has on profitability and sustainability.
Whilst there are company culture and structural issues in reorganising and implementing a holistic employer branding function if the trend of appointing employer brand managers continues as it is has in the USA, Europe and the UK over the past few years there is no doubt the role of the employer brand leader will become more commonplace in places such as Russia, Brazil, UAE, Poland and Asia as companies in these regions seek the benefits gained by those companies who are already three to five years into their journey.
Figure 10: The rise in employer brand leadership
10.Digitalise your employer brand strategy and think mobile first
The digital technologies underlying talent attraction, engagement and retention may not be new, but they are being used to new effect. Enormous amounts of information are accessible as never before-from what’s being said about your company online to internal forums focused on improving business processes.
Analytical and processing capabilities have made similar leaps with algorithms scattering intelligence across digital networks. Mobile devices such as smartphones, tablets and phablets make that information and computing power accessible to users around the world.
As these technologies gain momentum, they are profoundly changing the strategic context of employer branding. Research by Employer Brand International found social media (58%) to be the number one channel for communicating the employer brand whilst only 21% are using a mobile optimised career website to communicate their employer brand.
Companies such as Orange have innovated in the use of mobile technologies and have adopted a one platform for content and services to be broadcast on multi-screen, multi-channel and multi-lingual (one multilingual cms + delegation can be given to countries) see figure 11.
Figure 11: Mobile optimisation at Orange
11.Make sense of big data at your disposal
There are two types of data, 1) data that is technical in nature but complex and challenging to understand what it is telling us and 2) data that is easy to understand and provides for solutions that will impact on corporate performance.
Using the visualisation tool OrgVue, it easier for companies to get insights out of the data they already sit on. Figure 12 details a visualisation made for a 10,000 person haulage company:
All the dots in the images are people. The tool allows you to colour people based on anything you want. From the way the data is presented you are able to identify quite easily a few interesting relationships such as:
There’s a relationship between tenure and the ability to meet sales targets - (raises the question, should I change sales targets for people who start working here?)
There are diversity imbalances - (raises the question, how do I address this?)
In the LinkedIn example in Figure 13 the platform is mined to show the number of IT engineers in the USA based on the number of job listings in each city.
Analysing the data further allows you to better target your employer branding communications to ensure you reach the talent you are trying to hire. Don’t fish where everyone else is fishing! Find where the hidden gems of talent are and engage with those.
Figure 12: Making sense of big data
Figure 13: Talent identification with LinkedIn
12.Look outside your own borders
As talent from emerging markets join online professional networks it will create challenges and well as opportunities as companies are forced to expand their market reach beyond their own borders and tap into the on-demand workforce which is experiencing significant growth as barriers to entry decrease in industries such as taxi's, home help and fast food. Even in the employer brand industry new business models are launching which reduces the time to audit and develop an employer brand strategy in half simply by using smart technologies to collect internal and external insights compared to the traditional cumbersome face-face focus groups and leadership interviews. Not only is time saved but the cost is also reduced.
Research by PwC and LinkedIn assessed country's talent adaptability which is the rate at which people switch between roles and sectors, the rate at which they’re promoted and the number of jobs left open in a market (see figure 14). The research found visibility from online professional networks leads to better hiring. Online professional networks give organisations access to a larger talent pool and critically, to passive candidates as well as those actively looking for a job. Similarly, talented people can explore well beyond their own borders and have access to far more information on potential employers.
Figure 14: The link between talent adaptability and online professional network use
13.Foster relevant lifelong learning
For the cost of under $500 for a tablet or smartphone companies can put self-learning at the fingertips of employees and train them how to get the information to come to them. People are already questioning the value of University education at a time when course fees are increasing at a rate well above inflation and a degree no longer guarantees a job especially in service functions such as HR, marketing and communications.
There are an increasing number of open source free education websites available to anyone with an internet connection (see figure 15).
An open-source curriculum (OSC) is an online instructional resource that can be freely used, distributed and modified. OSC is based on the open-source practice of creating products or software that opens up access to source materials or codes. Applied to education, this process invites feedback and participation from developers, educators, government officials, students and parents and empowers them to exchange ideas, improve best practices and create world-class curricula. These 'development' communities can form ad-hoc, within the same subject area or around a common student need, and allow for a variety of editing and workflow structures.
One such OSC is MIT OpenCourseWare (MIT OCW) which is an initiative of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) to put all of the educational materials from its undergraduate- and graduate-level courses online, partly free and openly available to anyone, anywhere.
Figure 15: Open-source curriculum
14. Your network is your networth
What is the benchmark for the size of your connections on the major social media networks. Over the past few years I have found from personal experience that 1000 connections each across LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook is a significant number to build value with. However with the speed at which these platforms grow and mature I believe that number should be pushing to 2000 across each of the platforms in 2015 (see figure 16).
The key is to continually organically grow your network. Ensure you have global reach on your network and it is diverse enough to ensure you are learning and connecting with people from a range of talent from different backgrounds. I encourage students in our Certificate in Employer Brand Leadership course to connect with at least 50 other employer brand leaders and also other interesting people outside this group such as HR, marketing and communication professionals, agency heads and industry thought leaders.
Figure 16: Your network is your networth
15.Optimise communication flows inside and outside your organisation
There are a range of tools such as IBM’s social software solutions to support the communication flow inside and outside your organisation. These tools assist organisations of all sizes to work smarter, become more agile, and foster innovation.
Soxedo USA has been innovators in the use of social tools to enhance employer branding communications internally. Having a successful social media program that is highly visible has led to a high degree of cooperation between the Talent Acquisition team and other divisions. Other sections of Human Resources, as well as Marketing, Sales, Diversity, and Corporate Communications, now use the Sodexo social media presence to better launch initiatives and connect with clients.
Sodexo’s mobile initiative aims to help them meet the company’s ambitious growth goals by expanding their reach and engagement with candidates – both internally and externally – by providing on-the-go access to all of their online properties where they can interact with recruiters on the social network of their choice. What’s even better is that they can search and apply for jobs directly from their mobile device regardless of immediate access to a desktop computer. Their employees can also make referrals directly from the mobile app anytime, anywhere.
And some final thoughts…………………………
Build employer brand leadership capability
Managing the employee experience across the employment lifecycle should be a shared responsibility.
Employer brand leaders need to build awareness and capability in employer branding principles and practices across the organisation rather than relying on only one or two leaders to manage the function as has been traditional practice.
Train leaders in employer branding and educate them on the role of employer branding in contributing to company value. As a minimum teach leaders to answer the following questions:
What is employer branding?
Why is it important?
Which companies are leading the way in employer brand strategy?
How do we measure return on investment (ROI) of employer branding?
How will market trends impact on how we attract, engage and retain talent over the next 5 years!
10 years ago employer branding was a nice to have. It has now become a strategic imperative and whilst we see companies such as Google, Amtrak, UnitedHealth Group, LinkedIn, Marriott, Ferrero IKEA and Nike adopt a strategic approach to employer branding the majority of companies are still focused on using employer branding for recruitment only leading to an employee experience that is inconsistent, disjointed and far from what was promised on their way in to your organisation.
The 3rd Edition of "The Rise of Employer Brand Leadership" includes updated global research findings and new employer brand leader job descriptions from companies such as Facebook. Marriott and Coca Cola Hellenic, etc.
An analysis of employer brand leadership job and person descriptions over the past five years shows a diversity of approaches used by organisations when recruiting employer branding leaders. The focus for the employer brand leader is on recruitment at companies such as Facebook, Amazon and KPMG.
However companies such as Linkedin, Nike and Amtrak have adopted a holistic approach to employer branding across the total employment experience.
To download the whitepaper, "The rise of employer brand leadership" including 26 sample job descriptions from companies including Facebook, Nike, Mars, Google, Linkedin, Amazon, Standard Chartered Bank, E&Y, see below